If you can't see this e-mail, click here to view it online.
Celebrating Hawaii's best journalism
Please join us on June 24 to honor the brightest work by Hawaii's journalists in 2010. View the invitation below for more information.
Media Shield Law lives to see another two years
By Nancy Cook Lauer
It went right down to the wire, but it looks like SPJ-Hawaii was able to salvage the
state's Shield Law, at least for another two years. The law, which protects sources,
raw video, audio and notes by preventing a court from forcing a journalist or blogger to
reveal them, passed the Legislature in 2009 but was scheduled to lapse June 30.
While lobbying in support of or opposition to bills is a routine function of SPJ during the
legislative session, this year required a pull-out-all-stops approach just to get the bill
(HB 1376) heard in the Senate. The holdup was Sen. Clayton Hee, a Kahuku, Laie,
Kaaawa, Kaneohe Democrat who chairs the Senate Judiciary and Labor Committee.
The House version, sponsored by both the majority and minority leadership,
unanimously passed the House on March 4 and was sent to the Senate. There it sat
for another month, with Hee declining to schedule it for his committee. A concerted
campaign of telephone calls, personal visits and emails by SPJ board members,
attorney Jeff Portnoy and a dozen SPJ member print, broadcast and online media
outlets finally got the bill scheduled just hours before the bill cutoff deadline. Talk about
a nail-biter!
SPJ had hoped to make the Shield Law permanent, after a three-year trial period
proved the measure didn’t do any harm and helped ensure a free press. But the Senate
amended the measure to give it another two-year trial, after the state Judiciary raised
the same issues it had raised in 2009. The Judiciary wants all changes to the rules of
evidence to go through its own committee and amendment procedure.
Interestingly enough, after raising those same arguments in 2009, the Judiciary failed
to take advantage of the last two-year trial. But this time, it is required by the bill to do
its research and bring a report to the Legislature no later than 20 days prior to the 2012
session.
The amended version passed both houses with Sen. Malama Solomon, D-Waimea,
Hamakua, Hilo, the only dissenter.
A huge sigh of relief all around. But, as famed coach Yogi Berra said, “It ain’t over ‘til it’s
over.”
Assuming Gov. Neil Abercrombie signs the bill or allows it to become law without his
signature, we still get to do it all over again. If not next year, then the year after that.
Nancy Cook Lauer is SPJ vice president, neighbor island representative and a reporter
for West Hawaii Today.
HAWAI‘I CHAPTER SPJ // P.O. BOX 3141 // HONOLULU, HI 96802
|